By J.T. O’Donnell
With the creation of blogs has come a wonderful opportunity for people to become better informed on a variety of topics. Just visit www.Alltop.com and you’ll find a ‘magazine rack effect’ of blogs on almost any subject you can think of. In fact, when you click on the careers tab, you’ll find plenty of content providing advice. However, not all of it is worth taking.
Blog readers beware! Some online writers aren’t giving accurate or sound advice. Here’s why…
As more blogs are created, it gets harder for sites to increase readership. So, the need to stand out becomes critical. It starts with crafting intriguing titles for their posts so they can capture a reader’s attention and get that all-important ‘click’ on to the site. But, when that doesn’t result in enough hits, a blogger may opt to go beyond the headline and into the body of text with advice and commentary meant to shock and gain attention. There’s an old saying, “any publicity is good publicity,” and many bloggers today are embracing that strategy. They believe that creating a buzz is more important than creating a valuable resource. Sadly, the result is a lot of bloggers offering insights that are more than just a little off-base.
So, how does an innocent reader do a litmus test to make sure what they are reading is viable advice? A few suggestions:
1) Confirm the author can back up their advice with reputable facts. A single success is an accident. 2-5 times could still be just luck. But, an ability to provide dozens of examples – now that’s a fact.
2) Assess the credibility of the source. What’s the writer’s credentials? Should they be giving you advice on this subject? What qualifies them?
3) Follow your gut’s BS meter. A simple but true test. If the advice flies in convention and makes you think, “Really? Why then aren’t more people embracing it?” Leave it alone and let someone else try it first.
When we reached out to the current career experts (all 15 of them!) donating their time to answer career questions from followers of the Twitter Advice Project (T.A.P. into CAREREALISM), we chose people with a wide range of experience. The key word in that phrase: experience. Better still, we chose a large number of experts to participate so those seeking advice could see the collective thoughts of the group on the subject. This enables us to offer advice consensus and deliver a comprehensive answer to each career question received. It’s a known fact the IQ of a group is always higher than the average of its participants. So, it only made sense that we would create a career advice tool that would leverage the power of a team.
In closing, I ask you this:
At the end of the day, would you take medical advice from a team of doctors with PhDs and a successful track record of healing, or would you go with the Witch Doctor in the crazy outfit who just landed on the scene?
It’s your career, treat it well. Seek advice from credible sources to ensure you get the right advice. The health of your career is at stake.
![]() |
Write for this blog! Click here » if you're a credible career coach or business. |















12 Comments
This is a brilliant and very important message for job seekers. While all bloggers can bring something to the table, those looking for jobs and career advancement should use their intuition when taking advice and always read from credible sources!!
This is a brilliant and very important message for job seekers. While all bloggers can bring something to the table, those looking for jobs and career advancement should use their intuition when taking advice and always read from credible sources!!
This is a brilliant and very important message for job seekers. While all bloggers can bring something to the table, those looking for jobs and career advancement should use their intuition when taking advice and always read from credible sources!!
Great post. It's also important to remember that when it comes to career advise there are often several “right answers”. Anyone reading a post should consider their personal situation and see if the advise makes sense for them, in their life, in their situation. That is why having a career mentor, or at the very least someone to bounce important decisions off of, is critical.
BTW – If Career Realism wants a new super charged, leading edge coach with 20+ years of experience to enter the mix – The Job Search Ninja is ready to play!
Thanks JT and crew.
Todd Bavol –
Follow me on Twitter @jobsearchninja
The “danger” of the internet is that anyone can post anything and say it is a “credible source”. It is very important to be able to distinguish between what is and what is not credible.
The tips J.T. offers in this article are very important to use when evaluating the credibility of a site. Although it may seem like good information, looking up other articles/posts by that same author are necessary steps to take.
By the way, for those of you who are new to CAREEREALISM, J.T. is a credible source.
Thanks for the plug Andrew! Although, I'm sure some folks don't like my advice either. That's where the 'gut check' is so key. I know my approach isn't right for all parties, but I do try to make sure I can back it up with facts.
Now, I'm going to have to pay you for your vote of confidence. What's the going rate? Would $5 cover it?
I was looking recently at the career advice requests people make on Yahoo Answers. While some of the advice people give can be insightful informative and interesting, there's also lots of misleading and downright wrong advice. The peer to peer nature of social web tools is encouraging many to bypass professional advisers. Instead they can get instant advice from anyone who happens to be online at the time and wants to offer an opinion. Sometimes you get helpful advice from someone actually doing the job or course you are enquiring about…. but this does not seem to be the norm. Often bias, prejudice and steretypical ideas creep into the responses.
So thanks for this article – it's an important reminder to check out the credentials of whoever is offering you advice, so you can attach appropriate weight to it alongside other sources.
Thanks for pointing that out! Yahoo is a well-known site, and actually offers a lot of insightful articles by experts, but I've also seen a lot of bad advice circulating though their social media platform which they have no control over.
I'm glad you agree with the idea to 'kick the tires' before you drive off with the advice.
Thanks for sharing!
Is this in reference to a certain blogger advising job seekers that it's okay to burn bridges? I agree wholeheartedly that you should pay attention to the credibility of the person giving the advice. Jobacle had a post about this fairly recently… http://www.jobacle.com/blog/2009/1/28/beware-of…
That's funny you should mention that Ben… it's not about Rebecca's post. I know her and have even spoken on the phone with her. She is a talented person who is very focused on her career.
I have been watching what's been happening with her post over at BC. Moreover, I've been sent several articles lately from young job seekers who know me and have gotten advice directly from me that has worked. They send me the articles because they know I will get a kick out of it when I see how off-base the advice being given is. What scares me is how they will say in their e-mail, “I'm so glad you coached me because I would have actually thought this advice made sense if you hadn't taught me why it's such a bad idea.” That really makes me sad. For every one person I've helped, there are thousands who don't know any better.
It's the shiny object phenom – boring, but true often loses out to wrong but exciting. So, I wrote the post just hoping to get a few people to think twice. Let's hope it works!
*fingers crossed*
Agree!
A good dose of simple common sense helps as well.