Should I Offer to Work for Free?

Advertisement

‘JT & Dale Talk Jobs’ is the largest nationally syndicated career advice column in the country and can be found at JTandDale.com.

Dear J.T. & Dale: There’s a job opening at a local hospital for a health information tech, which is the job I am currently studying for. Is it OK to offer my volunteer services for a job? I’d do it to get the position and get some experience in the field. However, I spoke to someone who told me that volunteering does not count as “experience.” What do you say? — Shaista

Dale: While I agree that it would be extremely useful experience, I can’t imagine the hospital accepting your offer. Why not? First, the goal of most department managers is to hire the person who needs the least training/hand-holding. A volunteer would look like a lot of work and a distraction. Plus, a manager is going to think, “If you aren’t getting paid, what’s to keep you from taking off whenever you feel like it?” And, beyond all that, the manager would know that in organizational life and logic, if you don’t hire an employee to fill a position, there’s a good chance that the slot will get taken away. Take all those together, and the typical manager will not even give serious thought to taking you on as a volunteer. Besides, coming in with “I’ll work for free” will not make a compelling case for hiring you — it’ll just seem desperate.

J.T.: I would agree…IF you just offer to take the job opening at no pay. Instead, put the proposition in language that the manager can accept: Ask if you could come in as an intern. If you explain how it would complement your coursework, there’s a good chance they’d love to have you join the group, especially if you bring energy and enthusiasm.

Dale: That’s a good solution. And “intern” will be more impressive than “volunteer” when looking for a job. However, if the internship idea doesn’t work, do look for ways to volunteer at the hospital, just not as a “free employee.”

J.T.: It isn’t true that volunteering doesn’t count as experience. Even if you aren’t getting paid, you are learning while meeting people who eventually could serve as references or networking contacts.

Dale: Volunteering may not be the ideal resume item, but you’ll make yourself an insider, and that could make all the difference. One analysis of hiring in the current economy shows that “inside” hiring has dramatically increased — half of available jobs are filled by people already inside the company. And that doesn’t count employee referrals. In this, the Time of No Time, managers want to avoid doing an extensive search, and they don’t want to risk a bad hire — so why not turn to a bright volunteer or intern? Why not you?


jt-dale-logo

Jeanine “J.T.” Tanner O’Donnell is a professional development specialist and the founder of the consulting firm, jtodonnell.com, and of the blog, CAREEREALISM.com. Dale Dauten resolves employment and other business disputes as a mediator with AgreementHouse.com.

Please visit them at jtanddale.com, where you can send questions via e-mail, or write to them in care of King Features Syndicate, 300 W. 57th St, 15th Floor, New York, NY 10019.

© 2010 by King Features Syndicate, Inc.

CAREEREALISM

This career advice site provides daily personal branding tips and job search advice from approved career experts and businesses to over 600,000 visitors each month.

8 comments

  1. I agree with the article, asking for a job while not being paid for it is very desperate but telling that it could be done for the experience and in love with that’s a great idea!

  2. Yesterday, Yao Ming, Pu cunxin and other stars lead the 100 + from Sichuan, Qinghai and other disaster relief of poverty among children visited the Expo portion of the stadium. This is Yao Ming, Star December 2009 in Shanghai launched the “Star” with a look at the World Expo mbt shoes event, the “little giant” debut Expo.
    Yao ming said: “Let me visit Saudi Museum experience, but today the largest harvest or see the children are innocent smile, I dream is to have more children go to visit the Expo, so they all have a bright future. “In addition, Yao said that this time the there is a special harvest, is to” find mbt walking shoes a lot and I have the same dreams, a lot of discount mbt shoes resonance. ”

  3. Yesterday, Yao Ming, Pu cunxin and other stars lead the 100 + from Sichuan, Qinghai and other disaster relief of poverty among children visited the Expo portion of the stadium. This is Yao Ming, Star December 2009 in Shanghai launched the “Star” with a look at the World Expo mbt shoes event, the “little giant” debut Expo.
    Yao ming said: “Let me visit Saudi Museum experience, but today the largest harvest or see the children are innocent smile, I dream is to have more children go to visit the Expo, so they all have a bright future. “In addition, Yao said that this time the there is a special harvest, is to” find mbt walking shoes a lot and I have the same dreams, a lot of discount mbt shoes resonance. ”

  4. Could there then be a better way to tone up when the only fitness aid you need is a pair of
    ” mbt walking shoes”? MBT shoes can have a beneficial effect on the entire body and MBT shoes are said to enhance both training and massage effects on the body,MBT shoes are most definitely not a fashion statement and can look a bit odd. Invented in 1997 by Swiss Engineer Karl Mueller, ” mbt shoes “ are seen as a highly performing aid to fitness. MBT's are designed to be breathable, flexible and comfortable. The MBT shoes uniquely designed sole, very similar to the 'tyre shoes' often worn by East African Tribal people, are said to mimic walking around barefoot in the sand. As revered as the” discontinued mbt shoes” is, There is still some negativity associated with it. There are various cons related to the” discontinued mbt shoes”shoes, however the cost is one of the leading negatives.

  5. Have you heard of
    ” mbt shoes “?More and more people are pay more attention to health,so exercise with ” mbt shoes “ are so popular.maybe you are lack of a pair of “Cheap mbt Shoes on Sale “,there are good chance for you to choose shoe on
    ” mbt shoes sale “,disount mbt shoes are the trends,do you like ” mbt walking shoes”,mbt lami shoes,mbt sport shoes,mbt chapap shoes and mbt m. ” discontinued mbt shoes”walk shoes are the newest stylish mbt walking shoes,you can get the big benefit from the “Cheap mbt Shoes on Sale “ or
    “mbt shoes stores “ ? ” mbt shoes sale “are on hot sale in UK,can't you miss this chance?

  6. My question is that if you already have a full time position and wanting to move up, how do you gain the experience? What do you do if you have already graduated and wanting a position in your (new) field of choice? I find that often employers ask for experience as well. The issue is that once graduated it is had to find a position that would allow you to gain the needed experience – especially at the upper levels. How would one seek an externship? And how would someone who is working full time be able to find and work an externship? I am finding this to be the case with many of my former MBA classmates. Many who had a job going into their MBA still do but are not offered any advancement, and those who didn't still don't have jobs.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *